Best Hotels Honors Guide Credit Cards Brand Guide

How I rate Hilton hotels

How I rate Hilton hotels

Last updated November 14, 2026

Hotels I have stayed at get a rating out of 5. Every other hotel page on this site is a guide built from Hilton’s data, award prices and published guest reviews, and carries no rating. Here is what the number measures on the rated reviews and what each band means.

Which hotels carry a rating

As of October 14, 2026, 26 hotels carry a rating, each in a full review built from my folios and booking confirmations: Waldorf Astoria Las Vegas (4.4), Cliffrose Springdale (4.3), Hoodoo Moab (4.3), Hilton Sedona Resort at Bell Rock (4.3), The Foundry Hotel Asheville (4.2), The Art Hotel Denver (4.2), Embassy Suites by Hilton Gatlinburg Resort (4.2), Casa Marina Key West (4.1), Black Fox Lodge Pigeon Forge (4.1), DoubleTree by Hilton at the Entrance to Universal Orlando (4.1), Hilton Orlando Buena Vista Palace (4.0), The Charter Hotel Seattle (4.0), Embassy Suites by Hilton Boulder (4.0), Hampton Inn Sedona (4.0), Hilton Anaheim (3.9), Hilton Orlando Bonnet Creek (3.9), Hampton Inn Savannah Historic District (3.9), Hampton Inn Boston Seaport (3.9), Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront (3.9), Embassy Suites by Hilton Portland Airport (3.9), Hilton San Diego Bayfront (3.8), Embassy Suites by Hilton Washington DC Georgetown (3.8), Hilton Los Angeles/Universal City (3.8), Hilton Motif Seattle (3.8), Hilton Atlanta (3.7) and Hilton Clearwater Beach (3.6).

The brand reviews of Home2 Suites, Homewood Suites, DoubleTree and Tru carry one too, because I have stayed at 2 or more hotels in each. Every guide page opens with a line that says it’s a guide and when its details were checked.

Advertisement

My stay record

107 Hilton stays at 92 hotels, from June 2018 to August 2026, taken from my Hilton folios and booking confirmations. They are grouped by brand, newest first. Hotels with a full review are linked, with the rating.

Waldorf Astoria (1 stay)

Curio Collection (13 stays)

Tapestry Collection (3 stays)

Hilton Hotels & Resorts (14 stays)

Canopy by Hilton (1 stay)

  • Canopy by Hilton Portland Waterfront, Portland, ME: May 2024

Embassy Suites (10 stays)

DoubleTree (9 stays)

  • DoubleTree by Hilton at the Entrance to Universal Orlando (4.1), Orlando, FL: October 2025, October 2024, September 2023, September 2021
  • DoubleTree by Hilton Amsterdam Centraal Station, Amsterdam, Netherlands: December 2024
  • DoubleTree by Hilton Jacksonville Riverfront, Jacksonville, FL: June 2024
  • DoubleTree by Hilton Los Angeles Downtown, Los Angeles, CA: August 2021
  • DoubleTree by Hilton Tucson Downtown Convention Center, Tucson, AZ: August 2021
  • DoubleTree Suites by Hilton Phoenix, Phoenix, AZ: May 2021

Hilton Garden Inn (7 stays)

  • Hilton Garden Inn Seattle Airport, Seattle, WA: May 2025
  • Hilton Garden Inn Seattle Issaquah, Issaquah, WA: May 2025
  • Hilton Garden Inn Salt Lake City Airport, Salt Lake City, UT: October 2021
  • Hilton Garden Inn Idaho Falls, Idaho Falls, ID: October 2021
  • Hilton Garden Inn Phoenix Downtown, Phoenix, AZ: April 2021
  • Hilton Garden Inn Denver, Denver, CO: September 2020
  • Hilton Garden Inn Portland Waterfront, Portland, ME: August 2019

Hampton (26 stays)

  • Hampton Inn & Suites Leavenworth, Leavenworth, WA: August 2026
  • Hampton Inn Savannah Historic District (3.9), Savannah, GA: October 2025
  • Hampton Inn & Suites Chattanooga Downtown, Chattanooga, TN: September 2025
  • Hampton Inn & Suites Bend, Bend, OR: September 2025
  • Hampton Inn & Suites Hood River, Hood River, OR: August 2025
  • Hampton Inn & Suites Quebec City Beauport, Quebec City, Canada: June 2025
  • Hampton Inn Murphy, Murphy, NC: November 2024
  • Hampton Inn & Suites Rochester Downtown, Rochester, NY: August 2024
  • Hampton Inn Geneseo, Geneseo, NY: August 2024
  • Hampton Inn Crossville, Crossville, TN: August 2024
  • Hampton Inn Boston Seaport (3.9), Boston, MA: May 2024 (2 stays)
  • Hampton Inn Bar Harbor, Bar Harbor, ME: May 2024, August 2019
  • Hampton Inn Oak Ridge, Oak Ridge, TN: March 2024
  • Hampton Inn Johnson City, Johnson City, TN: January 2024
  • Hampton Inn Rawlins, Rawlins, WY: August 2023
  • Hampton Inn Oakhurst-Yosemite, Oakhurst, CA: May 2023
  • Hampton Inn & Suites Springdale-Zion National Park, Springdale, UT: December 2022
  • Hampton Inn Sedona (4.0), Sedona, AZ: November 2022
  • Hampton Inn New Smyrna Beach, New Smyrna Beach, FL: May 2022
  • Hampton Inn Richfield, Richfield, UT: April 2021
  • Hampton Inn Moab, Moab, UT: April 2021
  • Hampton Inn Biloxi, Biloxi, MS: January 2020
  • Hampton Inn Charleston Historic District, Charleston, SC: November 2019
  • Hampton Inn Raleigh Downtown, Raleigh, NC: March 2019

Homewood Suites (9 stays)

  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Seattle-Issaquah, Issaquah, WA: August 2026
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Salt Lake City Airport, Salt Lake City, UT: April 2025
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Cathedral City Palm Springs, Cathedral City, CA: February 2025
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Louisville, Louisville, KY: August 2023
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Topeka, Topeka, KS: August 2023
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Boise, Boise, ID: August 2023
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Clovis, Clovis, CA: May 2023
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Savannah Historic District, Savannah, GA: March 2022
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Jackson, Jackson, WY: October 2021

Home2 Suites (12 stays)

  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Roanoke, Roanoke, VA: November 2025
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Chicago McCormick Place, Chicago, IL: October 2025
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Jacksonville Downtown, Jacksonville, FL: June 2024
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton El Paso, El Paso, TX: February 2024 (2 stays)
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Carlsbad, Carlsbad, NM: February 2024
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Johnson City, Johnson City, TN: March 2023
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Idaho Falls, Idaho Falls, ID: October 2021
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Page Lake Powell, Page, AZ: April 2021
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Jekyll Island, Jekyll Island, GA: August 2020
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Seattle Airport, Seattle, WA: May 2019
  • Home2 Suites by Hilton Macon I-75 North, Macon, GA: June 2018

Tru by Hilton (2 stays)

  • Tru by Hilton Beckley, Beckley, WV: November 2023
  • Tru by Hilton Cheyenne, Cheyenne, WY: July 2022

What the score covers

The score answers one question: how good is this hotel for a Hilton Honors member paying with points or cash. It’s weighted across 5 things.

  • Points value. What a night costs in points against what it costs in cash, in cents per point. This carries the most weight.
  • Room and building condition. How recently the rooms were renovated and how the building holds up in daily use.
  • What Diamond status gets you here. Upgrade odds, breakfast or the food and beverage credit, lounge access where there’s a lounge.
  • Location. Whether the site is the reason to book, and what you can reach on foot.
  • Cost beyond the room rate. Resort and destination fees, parking, and how far a meal on property runs.
Advertisement

What each band means

  • 4.5 to 5.0. Book it. Points clear strong value, the rooms are current, and Diamond benefits land most stays.
  • 4.0 to 4.4. Worth booking on the right dates. Usually one weak spot: a fee, a dated room tier, or award pricing that only works off-peak.
  • 3.5 to 3.9. Book it for the location or the rate, knowing what you are giving up.
  • 3.0 to 3.4. There’s a better Hilton nearby, or the points cost doesn’t justify the stay.
  • Below 3.0. Something is wrong: rooms in poor condition, fees that swallow the value, or a property that doesn’t deliver what its brand promises. A 2 means I wouldn’t book it again.

Why the range is narrow

Most scores on this site sit between 3.6 and 4.4, and here is why.

Ratings only go on hotels I have stayed at, so the sample is small and leans toward hotels I chose to book. A Waldorf Astoria is marked against other Waldorf Astorias, not against a roadside Hampton Inn.

Each score comes from my own stay, checked against published rates, award pricing and property details.

Where a hotel has a real problem, the review says so in the trade-offs section, and the score reflects it. Read that section before the number to see the weak spots.

2 things the score leaves out

Star ratings and brand tiers measure the class of the hotel. Neither tracks whether a stay is worth your points, so they don’t feed the score.

Aggregate guest review scores measure satisfaction across every kind of traveler. I read them, and they stay out of the number.

How to use it

Compare scores within a city or within a brand. A 4.4 in Savannah against a 4.1 in Savannah is a useful comparison. A 4.4 Curio against a 4.4 Waldorf isn’t, because they are being judged against different expectations.

If 2 hotels score the same, read the points value line on each. That is usually where the decision is.

The scores sit only on the hotels I have stayed at. Start with the best Hilton hotels overall, or browse every hotel page on the site. If you want to know who is doing the rating, that is on the about page.

What gets checked on every property

The 5 inputs above are scored from the same checklist, in the same order, on every review. It’s deliberately boring, because a method that changes per hotel isn’t a method.

  • Award price against cash price on the same dates. Every review prices at least 1 midweek and 1 weekend date and reports cents per point.
  • The fifth-night rule. Every member gets the 5th night free on a Standard Room Reward stay of 5 or more nights booked fully with points, per the Hilton Honors terms checked October 5, 2026. Any property where a 5-night stay is realistic gets priced both ways.
  • Room types. The room I booked, from the confirmation, against the room types Hilton lists today. Room condition counts only where my records cover it.
  • The published elite benefit against the property reality. Hilton lists the Gold and Diamond benefit as a “Daily Food & Beverage Credit or Continental Breakfast (varies by brand and region)”. The review records what the specific hotel does, and says so when the hotel doesn’t publish it.
  • Everything charged on top of the room. Resort or destination charges, parking, and whether the resort charge is waived on award stays. Hilton states that reward stays carry no resort fees for all tiers, so the review flags any property where the cash rate and the award rate differ on this.
  • What the hotel doesn’t publish. If a figure isn’t on hilton.com or the property page, the review says “not published”.

What pulls a score down, and what disqualifies a property

Some things cost a property a few tenths. Others stop it being recommended at all.

  • A fee that isn’t disclosed at booking costs more than a fee that is.
  • Award pricing that only works off-peak caps a property in the 3s. If the points math falls apart on the dates most people travel, the score reflects the dates most people travel.
  • A renovation that has reached some floors and not others is scored on the floors you are likely to be given, not the ones in the photographs.
  • Rooms in poor condition put a property below 3.0 on their own, whatever the location does for it.
  • A property that doesn’t deliver what its brand promises. A Waldorf Astoria without Waldorf service is marked against Waldorf Astoria, not against the town it sits in.
Advertisement

Money, links and conflicts of interest

This site earns commission. Here is exactly how that works and where the line sits.

  • Every outbound link to hilton.com and americanexpress.com carries rel="sponsored nofollow". There are 874 of them across the site, and they are the only links that earn anything. The full terms are on the affiliate disclosure page.
  • Links to the National Park Service, tourism boards, Hilton’s newsroom and other reference sources carry no sponsorship and earn nothing. There are 28 of those, and they exist because a claim needed a source.
  • A commission doesn’t move a score. The 5 inputs are the only things the number is built from, and none of them has a field for what a booking pays.
  • No hotel or brand pays for placement, for a score, or to be added to the directory.

If you think a score is wrong, the contact page takes corrections. Anything factual that turns out to be wrong gets changed and the change gets dated.

Frequently asked questions

What does a score out of 5 mean here?

It answers one question: how good is this hotel for a Hilton Honors member paying with points or cash. It’s weighted across points value, room and building condition, what Diamond status delivers at that property, location, and cost beyond the room rate.

Why do most scores sit between 3.6 and 4.4?

Because ratings only go on hotels I have stayed at, and I chose to book those hotels. A Waldorf Astoria is marked against other Waldorf Astorias. The band is narrow because the sample is narrow.

What stops a property scoring well no matter how good the location is?

Rooms in poor condition put a property below 3.0 on their own. Award pricing that only works off-peak caps a property in the 3s. A property that doesn’t deliver what its brand promises is marked against that brand, not against the town it sits in.

Does the score include the fifth night free or the resort fee waiver?

Not directly. Both are program-wide: the fifth night is free on a standard room stay booked with 100% points for Silver members and above, and reward stays carry no resort fees for any tier. Source: Hilton Honors member benefits page, hilton.com, checked August 15, 2026. They affect what a stay costs you and leave the score alone.

Can a hotel pay to change its score?

No. Affiliate commission is earned on booking and card-offer links to hilton.com and americanexpress.com, which carry rel="sponsored nofollow". Plain source citations to those sites carry neither, and none of the 5 scoring inputs has a field for what a booking pays.

Hilton tips, no spam

2 emails a month with Hilton Honors changes, new guides and Hilton card news from a Diamond member.

About the author

John Bourscheid has been a Hilton Honors Diamond member since 2018 and has stayed at 92 Hilton hotels. He pays for his own stays and takes no press trips. Guides to hotels he hasn’t stayed at say so in their first line, and he says when a hotel isn’t worth the points.